Thursday, October 16, 2008

Epiphany

One particular moment sticks out at me as I finish the novel: the moment when, about to be beaten again without cause, Frado commands Mrs. Bellmont to "Stop," saying, "strike me, and I'll never work a mite more for you."  It seemed to me that this would always have been a legitimate threat, as Frado is a free woman, despite her lower class status.  I could understand that this was simply an avenue that she hadn't explored until this point, a thought so emboldened and outside the realm that it took Frado time to conceive of it.  But in my view, this could have been the end of the book (or the end of the story in real life, for that matter).  Wilson writes on the next page, "Thus passed a year.  The usual amount of scolding, but fewer whippings."  Why does Frado endure any whippings at all?  It is clear that Mrs. Bellmont needs her more than she needs Mrs. Bellmont.  She is in a position to resist the whippings, the kind of treatment that characterized her time with the Bellmonts to that point.  This should have been the end of such treatment, and, in essence, the end of the story, but it wasn't.  Frado in fact spends a good deal more time with her tyrant, and we never again see an instance when she herself refuses to be beaten.  Is this simply the result of a damaged psyche?  Or is there some other pragmatic concern that prevents her from acting that I just missed?

2 comments:

Katie Riera said...

The epiphany Ross comments on could be presented as the climax in the plot action. Frado had to work up the courage, gain an undestanding of religion, and come to terms more with herself before she was able to finally stand up to Mrs. B. It is her defining and shining moment in the novel, one that the reader has been waiting for since she was left at the Bellmont house. Frado finally asserts her freedom, and acts as a free woman instead their "Nig." However, after this outbreak Frado appears to lose strength and become more sickly. The falling action is when she moves from house to house, gets ill, has a family, and wanders.

Vu said...

To a certain degree, I think Frado has internalized her status as a second-class citizen. Consider this. She was born having to deal with the prejudices of being both black and white. Her mother left her at the age of six. She has practically nowhere to run to if she wishes to escape. Consequently, it may have been impossible for Frado to avoid internalizing the idea that she is a second-class citizen. Therefore, staying at Ms. Bellmont's abusive house may have only been a logical move for a girl whose self-esteem has been shattered.